top of page
Search

Techno-Economic Analysis: The Key to Cost-Effective Cultivated Meat Production.

  • Writer: Gustavo Valente
    Gustavo Valente
  • Jul 18, 2024
  • 4 min read
ree

Cultivated Meat represents a significant technological advancement with the potential to address global food security, environmental sustainability, and animal welfare offering a huge business opportunity globally. However, one of the primary challenges for the industry is achieving cost-competitiveness with conventional animal meat. 

Techno-economic analysis (TEA) plays a crucial role in identifying ways to reduce costs and achieve price parity. 

This article highlights the benefits of using TEA in cultivated meat production and explores strategies for cost reduction.

Understanding Techno-Economic Analysis (TEA)

Techno-economic analysis is a systematic approach that combines engineering, economic, and financial analyses to evaluate the viability and cost-effectiveness of new technologies. In the context of cultivated meat, TEA assesses various factors, including production processes, costs of goods sold (COGS), capital expenditures (CapEx), and operational expenditures (OpEx). This comprehensive analysis helps identify cost drivers and potential areas for optimization.

Benefits of TEA in Cultivated Meat Production


  1. Cost Identification and Reduction TEA enables the identification of the main cost components in cultivated meat production. TEA highlights specific areas where cost reductions are possible by breaking down the costs associated with cell culture media, bioreactors, labour, and other inputs. For instance, studies have shown that the cost of cell culture media, which accounts for a significant portion of production costs, can be reduced through the optimization of media formulation and recycling strategies.

  2. Process Optimization By analysing different production scenarios, TEA helps optimise the production process. For example, switching from batch to continuous or fed-batch processes can improve cell growth efficiency and reduce media consumption. Additionally, optimising bioreactor design and scale can lead to significant CapEx and OpEx savings.

  3. Optimum Production Scale TEA’s economies of scale analysis provides crucial insights into the ideal scale of production, pinpointing the most cost-effective production size that balances both capital and operational expenses. By evaluating various production scale scenarios, TEA identifies the thresholds at which the cost per unit of meat produced decreases significantly, allowing for maximized efficiency and profitability. Understanding the optimal industrial scale is essential for cultivated meat companies to achieve price parity with conventional meat while ensuring sustainable and scalable growth. 

  4. Scalability and Industrialization It helps in planning the transition from lab-scale to industrial-scale production by identifying potential bottlenecks and proposing solutions to overcome them. This includes the design and deployment of large-scale bioreactors and efficient downstream processing technologies.

  5. Economic Viability and Investment Decisions Investors and stakeholders require robust economic models to assess the commercial viability of cultivated meat ventures. TEA provides a detailed financial analysis, including return on investment (ROI), net present value (NPV), and payback period, which are essential for attracting funding and making informed investment decisions.


Key Strategies for Cost Reduction


  1. Optimization of Cell Culture Media The cost of cell culture media is one of the largest expenses in cultivated meat production. Strategies to reduce media costs include the use of cheaper ingredients, recycling media, and optimizing the composition to improve cell growth efficiency. Advances in metabolic engineering and synthetic biology can also contribute to developing more cost-effective media formulations.

  2. Bioprocessing Improvements Optimizing bioprocesses, such as fed-batch and continuous production, can enhance cell density and reduce media usage. Implementing perfusion systems, which continuously add and remove media, can maintain optimal growth conditions and improve productivity. However, the trade-offs between CapEx and OpEx must be carefully evaluated to determine the most cost-effective approach.

  3. Scale-Up and Industrialization Scaling up production to industrial levels is critical for reducing costs. Larger bioreactors benefit from economies of scale, reducing the cost per unit of meat produced. TEA helps design and plan for large-scale facilities, ensuring that they are economically viable and capable of meeting market demands.

  4. Hybrid Products Blending cultivated meat with plant-based or fermentation-derived ingredients can reduce costs and improve the nutritional profile of the final product. This approach leverages the strengths of different protein sources and can help achieve cost parity more quickly.

  5. Supply Chain Optimization Efficient supply chain management is essential for minimizing costs. TEA can identify opportunities for collaboration with suppliers, improving logistics, and reducing waste. By optimizing the supply chain, producers can lower the overall cost of production and enhance the sustainability of the cultivated meat industry.


As the cultivated meat industry continues to evolve, ongoing TEA will be essential for driving innovation and cost reduction. 

Future TEAs should incorporate real-world data from pilot and commercial-scale facilities to refine cost estimates and identify emerging challenges. TEA can provide a holistic view of the technical and economic aspects, ensuring that cultivated meat production is both scalable and economically viable.

Conclusion

TEA is a powerful tool for guiding the development and commercialization of cultivated meat. By identifying cost drivers and optimization opportunities, TEA helps the industry progress towards achieving price parity with conventional meat. 

The ongoing refinement of production processes, media formulations, and bioreactor designs, coupled with strategic investments and supply chain optimizations, will be crucial for the cultivated meat industry's success. As the industry scales and technology matures, cultivated meat has the potential to become a cost-competitive and sustainable alternative to traditional animal agriculture.

All cultivated meat startups and investors looking to leverage the full potential of Techno-Economic Analysis in their production processes, contact me, to discuss how I can support you to achieve cost-effective, scalable, and sustainable solutions in the cultivated meat industry. Let's innovate and drive this revolutionary industry forward. 

Please feel free to share this post with your network and let's continue to learn and grow together. 💪🌱

💬 Can't wait to hear your thoughts! Drop a comment below or reach out to me directly for engaging conversations. 🗣️💡


Gustavo Valente

Director, Sustech Innovation

WhatssApp +52 55 3405 0552


 
 
 

Comments

Rated 0 out of 5 stars.
No ratings yet
Add a rating
bottom of page